Innisfree Ranch
The Ethics Project

WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 9, 2009

Judge Orders Coverup




Well, is this ethical conduct on the judge's part? Is he helping ensure a fair trial or keeping important information about the character of the defendant from the jury?


ST. PETERSBURG, Florida (Reuters) – A neo-Nazi gang member went on trial for murder on Monday with his swastika and other tattoos covered by makeup on the order of a Florida judge who thought they could prejudice jurors.


The judge ordered the state to pay for a cosmetologist to apply makeup before trial each day to cover up the tattoos on John Ditullio's face and neck, which include a swastika, barbed wire and an obscene word.


Ditullio, 23, is charged with stabbing to death 17-year-old Kristofer King in 2006 in New Port Richey, north of St. Petersburg.


His lawyer argued in a pretrial motion that the tattoos, which Ditullio acquired after his arrest, could prejudice a jury. The judge agreed but ruled that any tattoos Ditullio had before his arrest should not be covered.


Ditullio could face the death penalty if convicted. (Reporting by Robert Green, editing by Jim Loney and Doina Chiacu)



I say it's wrong. The judge is essentially tampering with evidence. The defendant has a right to face his accuser. That's Constitutional law. But shouldn't the jury have the right to see the real defendant?

This is in a different category than buying the guy a new suite for the trial. If willing to carve a permanent hate slogan on your face, doesn't that say something about you that runs deeper than your choice of clothing?

What do you think?

Chris Reich, The Ethics Project


posted by CHRIS REICH, THE ETHICS PROJECT  December 09, 2009 12:59 

General   trackback URL (0)


I WANT YOUR COMMENTS! CLICK TO ADD YOUR   comments (0)


 




1 - 1 of 1



    RECENT ENTRIES


    Judge Orders Coverup

    -December 09, 2009


    Should We Measure Economic Recovery Using the DJIA?

    -April 12, 2010


    Do Successful Business People Make Good Government Leaders? Part 1

    -February 13, 2010


    As We Buy a "Made in China" Christmas

    -December 10, 2009


    A Question about an Estate

    -November 09, 2009


    RECENT COMMENTS

    Is it "Bleak House" or another Dickens novel that lays bare with such bitter humor ...

    -July 30, 2010


    Determined to crush they may be, but the church will survive, just like it did ...

    -July 30, 2010


    You had the answer on the first line. NO.

    If someone is not intentionally (meaning ...

    -September 21, 2009


    Mark,

    That was a brilliant essay on exactly what I believe would be the proper handling---I ...

    -September 20, 2009


    Do we report the oil leak and take the consequences, yes.

    First, order the line down ...

    -September 20, 2009


    CATEGORIES

    General (12)


    ARCHIVE

    april 2010


    february 2010


    december 2009


    november 2009


    october 2009


    september 2009


    august 2009





    admin*


    The Innisfree Ranch Ethics Project is a project of Chris Reich. You may use all material herein freely.

    Contact Chris@Innisfreeranch.com